What Makes a Vineyard Special? Wine Review: Panther Creek Shea Vineyard Willamette Valley Oregon 2011

What makes a vineyard special?  Names like la Tâche, Mesnil, To-Kalon, Beckstoffer, Richbourg, and Canubi get geeks swooning and burning their wallets.  But forget soil, weather, aspect, drainage, or anything physical. We usually prattle on about that stuff to justify taking out a second mortgage. No, human history and the arbiters of taste have made these sites more prized than their fancy dirt.

In Oregon, Shea vineyard in Yamhill-Carlton has a cult status. How did this happen?

Dundee and its rich, volcanic soil was all the rage in the 1980s. But the Shea family went West and planted in 1989 in Yamhill-Carlton. The soil is sedimentary over fractured sandstone: not Dundee. The site sits in a hilly pocket. It allows in fog but then gets hotter than others. This diurnal range would make for big Pinot.

Just as Shea’s grapes came online in the 1990s, winemaker Ken Wright’s fame was rising. He highlighted Shea with his Panther Creek winery, but after a few years he went independent. Then, with the 1994 vintage, Robert Parker, in all his majesty, gave Wright’s own Shea a 92 and Panther Creek’s Shea a 94: his highest score for Oregon yet (it probably did not hurt that Parker’s brother in law owned the plot next-door).

Shea had arrived.

Today, Shea spans 200 acres, with vines covering 140, 135 of which grow Pinot Noir. Vine spacing is 5 by 7 yielding 1,245 plants per acre. Jesus Marin supervises Shea’s 10 year-round workers, which balloon to 40, and then 150 by harvest. The Sheas use 25% and sell 75% to other winemakers.  But Dick Shea has tried to be picky about who gets what bit.

About 20 winemakers now have a finger in the Shea pie. Some include: Alexana, Antica Terra, Bergström, Boedecker Cellars, Chapter 24, Elk Cove, J.K. Carriere, Penner-Ash, Raptor Ridge, Rex Hill, Shea Wine Cellars (of course), Walt (a Napa Valley label), Stephen Goff, St. Innocent, and Winderlea.

Yet the original winner of this popularity contest remains Panther Creek.  But since Shea tends to be a Parker love-child of weight and intensity, let us go with a vintage that plays against type: 2011. Spring and Summer kept cool and wet, until a warm September brought in a healthy harvest. Thus, alcohols remained lower, acids higher, even for Shea.

Panther Creek Shea Vineyard Willamette Valley Oregon 2011 $52.00


The APPEARANCE looks clear, with a hazy iron rust rim that fades into a medium ruby core.

Clean, mellow AROMAS of clove, vanilla husk, and hazelnut lead. Fruit is secondary, think cherry skin and orange peel, ending in cooling iron.

The PALATE feels dry, supple, yet medium plus acidity, mild tannins, and medium alcohol frame a medium body with a raw silk texture.

FLAVORS remain sparkling, bright, mineral, and spiced, with bright orange and cranberry. However, these elements get numbed by a swath of velvet oak. Medium plus length.

Panther Creek’s 2011 Shea is very good (4 of 5), balancing a vibrant, lean vintage against vineyard-specific supple fruit. But 16 months of 30% new French oak barrels nearly kill it. Luckily, the quality fruit manages to shine.

Back to our original question. What makes a vineyard special? With Shea, good timing mattered. Parker was making big wines the rage. Ken Wright’s fame was rising. Shea’s vines were old enough. Their vineyard management was good enough. Then the hot 1994 vintage delivered.

Such ripeness is atypical of Oregon. Even a lean 2011 cannot hide Shea’s powerful fruit.  But really the collision of celebrity in Parker and Wright and fickle fashion’s love of big, dry, reds vaulted Shea to iconic status.

Context makes kings and queens.


About waywardwine

Follow Wayward Wine (WSET3) to tour the world's exciting vineyards, breweries, and distilleries, while discovering new drinks.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to What Makes a Vineyard Special? Wine Review: Panther Creek Shea Vineyard Willamette Valley Oregon 2011

  1. Great post! We live in Napa but have made the pilgrimmage up to Oregon several times since our soon started at U of O back in 2015. We’ve visited many of the wineries that source from Shea – Bergstrom probably my favorite. If I had to pick a single Oregon favorite, though, it would be Sass a bit farther south in Willamette. Check out our write up on our visit there: https://topochinesvino.com/2016/10/09/a-lot-of-sass-in-willamette-valley/

  2. whiskeyglob says:

    I am much glad to read about Napa. Napa is a famous place for producing wine. It is the famous city of USA. The huge quantity of wine is produced in this city. I also visit so many time in Napa Valley.
    glass liquor decanters

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s